The answer: Eli was on the left!
Here are the results of the voting:

Fields are as follows, each in quotes, separated by commas:
Left or Right, Date, Time

"Right","11/13/03","02:49:26 PM"
"Left","11/13/03","02:49:31 PM"
"Right","08/11/06","07:12:40 PM"
"Left","05/02/09","01:49:18 PM"
"Left","08/07/10","04:35:01 PM"